Submit a Story!
Dissecting Apple's "Multitouch" Patent: Can It Stop Palm? [Patent Wars]
Dissecting Apple's "Multitouch" Patent: Can It Stop Palm? [Patent Wars]
The iPhone’s multitouch patents are the equivalent of a cold war nuclear arsenal—dormant for now, but Palm’s Pre is looking for a fight. Here’s why we think Apple’s multitouch monopoly won’t last. To help guide us through, machete in hand, what is one of the more confusing jungles of U.S. law, ...
Despite iTunes Accord, Music Labels Still Fret
Despite iTunes Accord, Music Labels Still Fret
nytimes.com — The tension between Apple and the music industry stems from Apple’s power over the industry, but it... also echoes the traditional divide between suppliers and distributors. > (more) Despite iTunes Accord, Music Labels Still Fret
Apple vs. Palm: the in-depth analysis
Apple vs. Palm: the in-depth analysis
engadget.com — Apple and Palm kicked a lot of dirt at each other last week -- acting Apple CEO... Tim Cook flatly told analysts that "We will not stand for people ripping off our IP" when asked specifically about competition like the Palm Pre, and Palm responded ... (more) Apple vs. Palm: the in-depth analysis
Apple sued over 'broken promises' regarding 3G speeds
appleinsider.com — A new class-action lawsuit claims Apple knowingly profited from faulty iPhone 3Gs that couldn't stay connected to... the faster 3G network, costing buyers inferior service and missed opportunities to use an alternative provider. (more) Apple sued over 'broken promises' regarding 3G speeds
Comments
Blog Reactions

Gizmodo publishes an editorial entitled Dissecting Apple's "Multitouch" Patent: Can It Stop Palm?
PalmAddicts — ... [From Hans] Gizmodo publishes an editorial entitled Dissecting Apple's "Multitouch" Patent: Can It Stop Palm? "The iPhone’s multitouch patents are the equivalent of a cold war nuclear arsenal—dormant for now, but Palm’s Pre is looking for a fight. Here’s why we think Apple’s multitouch monopoly won’t last. To help guide us through, machete in hand, what is one of the more confusing jungles of U.S. law, we talked to R. Polk Wagner, a professor of patents law at the University of Pennsylvania Law School. He specializes in patents and intellectual property as it ...

RTFA: This Week In Giz Features [RTFA]
Gizmodo — Throughout the week, writers take time to write longer posts, in-depth original stories you may not have had time to read during the week. Now that it's Saturday, here's your chance to RTFA! Apple vs. Palm, Google, RIM and God knows who else: How the company will or won't defend its multitouch phone interface patent Bonus: All of Apple's bloodiest patent and copyright clashes, on one page Apple's iLife '09 Review Roundup: Our complete review of iPhoto '09 with tips Special: What to know about iPhoto '09 ...

iPhone multi-touch patent: The facts
infoSync World — ... was eventually rolled out, based on CIC's Jot handwriting recognition software. Gizmodo describes the "issues" between Apple and Palm as a "nuclear war", while ...

The curious case of iPhone multi-touch patent (Apple vs. Palm)
PalmAddicts — ... for us, end users and consumers it’s more interesting to know what is it about iPhone multi-touch patent that Apple plans to protect with whatever arsenals the company has. The curiosity is enough to make these three famous tech sites to published deeper analysts to look into the patent dispute: Nilay Patel from Engadget is helped by Mathew Gavronski, a patent attorney in the Chicago office of Michael Best & Friedrich. John Mahoney from Gizmodo is helped by R. Polk Wagner, a professor of patents law at the University of ...

What Using Windows 7 Multitouch is Like [Windows 7]
Gizmodo — ... Zoom: In spite of new concerns over multitouch patents, this zoom behavior is pretty much identical to the one seen in Apple products (and on Microsoft's Surface as well). You put two fingers on the screen and move them together to zoom out, and separate them to zoom in. I will note that this was easier to do with two hands—one-handed pinching was probably too micro for the TouchSmart screen. ...

Windows 7 Touch and Multitouch Video Walkthrough [Windows 7]
Gizmodo — ... Zoom: In spite of new concerns over multitouch patents, this zoom behavior is pretty much identical to the one seen in Apple products (and on Microsoft's Surface as well). You put two fingers on the screen and move them together to zoom out, and separate them to zoom in. I will note that this was easier to do with two hands—one-handed pinching was probably too micro for the TouchSmart screen. ...

Next Generation iPhone May Have Videoconferencing, At Last [IPhone 3G 2.0]
Gizmodo — ... Given Apple's focus on videoconferencing with iChat AV, I always found strange that there wasn't a front camera in the iPhone. Looking at their gigantic iPhone patent, it may be coming in the next generation: ...

Apple’s Multi-Touch Patent Revisited [TheAppleBlog]
GigaOM Network — ... I wrote about the patent Apple received for this, but I’d like to comment further in light of all the discussion going on about the relative usefulness of this patent. A lot of the discussion seems to stem from these sources: A Gizmodo article using a “professor of patents law” as a source.  An analyst report that claims Apple going after Palm could cause more harm than good. I do not dispute these are valid opinions, but so are the opposite. ...

Apple’s Multi-Touch Patent Revisited
TheAppleBlog — ... I wrote about the patent Apple received for this, but I’d like to comment further in light of all the discussion going on about the relative usefulness of this patent. A lot of the discussion seems to stem from these sources: A Gizmodo article using a “professor of patents law” as a source. An analyst report that claims Apple going after Palm could cause more harm than good. I do not dispute these are valid opinions, but so are the opposite. The tech world has set this up ...

Our Android T-Mobile G2 Wishlist [Android]
Gizmodo — ... . And we also know Google is scared of potential litigation from Apple. But until Android adds multitouch as a core service for every app developer to utilize in creative new ways, it won't be a cutting edge platform. ...

Apple's Legal Showdown Over Multitouch Begins, With Palm Nowhere To Be Seen [Multitouch]
Gizmodo — You know the patent Cold War that's been brewing over Apple's claimed exclusivity over multitouch tech? It just got hotter, but the heat comes not from the Palm Pre, but lil' old Elan Microelectronics. Elan is a Taiwan-based touchpad manufacturer, best known for supplying the touchpads on several Eee PC models. And apparently they've got a well-leveraged patent position on multitouch tech: last year, Elan and touchpad giant Synaptics came to a cross-licensing agreement after an initial injunction in a similar lawsuit ruled in Elan's favor. The case ...

Related Content
Apple’s Multi-Touch Patent: A More Realistic View [TheAppleBlog]
theappleblog.com 2/3/2009 — So Apple is finally awarded their multi-touch patent , and the hue and cry from the Apple Bashers is pretty loud. But not only Apple Bashers are worried, Daring Fireball had this to say : Very broad language - taken at face value, Apple ...
Apple Secures Multitouch Technology Patent
pcworld.com 1/28/2009 — We just discussed the saber-rattling from Palm and Apple , but here's another data point to throw into the mix. According to the United States Patent and Trademark Office--which we're going to go out on a limb and call a trustworthy source--Apple has ...
For What They’re Worth, Some Apple Phone Patent Filings
technologizer.com 1/23/2009 — I have no idea whether Apple will sue Palm or any other competitor for violating its intellectual property rights. But I do know this: I love patent drawings. So here are a few from Apple patent filings relating to touch interfaces and phones, which I ...
Palm to Apple: Bring It
digitaldaily.allthingsd.com 1/23/2009 — We like competition, as long as they don’t rip off our IP, and if they do, we’re going to go after anybody that does … We will not stand for having our IP ripped off and we’ll use whatever weapons we have at our disposal [to ...
Will Apple Sue Palm Over the Pre? - News and Analysis by PC Magazine
pcmag.com 1/22/2009 — Apple review, Apple commentary, Apple news... Everything Apple Apple executives hinted Wednesday that the company might legally contest the multitouch technology found within the Palm Pre. During the waning minutes of a conference call announcing the ...
Is Apple working on a next-gen iPhone with customized multi-core chips?
intomobile.com 2/5/2009 — By now it’s an accepted fact that Apple ( NSDQ: AAPL ) has loosed a fleet of next-generation iPhones for real-world testing. And, true to Apple’s usually secretive ways, the new “ iPhone 2,1 ” feature-set is still a mystery. ...
Palm vs Apple! Fight!
mobilewhack.com 1/23/2009 — Once the Palm Pre arrives we're going to see it battle Apple for the cell phone supremacy. Will we see them fight each other in court too? During Apple's performance report Tim Cook said Apple is more than ready to face off competition. Apple will go ...
Spotlight on Apple’s hidden revenue stream
apple20.blogs.fortune.cnn.com 1/20/2009 — On Wednesday, when Apple announces its fiscal 2009 first-quarter earnings, the business press will rush to report the key metrics: number of units sold for Macs, iPods and iPhones, as well as overall company sales, earnings, and gross margins. But ...
Apple and EFF argue over iPhone jailbreaking
appleinsider.com 2/13/2009 — The Electronic Frontier Foundation has filed requests with the US Copyright Office to exempt activities from legal threats under the DMCA, one of which attacks Apple's secured software business model on the iPhone.
★ Apple, Google, and Palm
daringfireball.net 2/10/2009 — M.G. Siegler has an intriguing report today regarding the lack of multi-touch support in the current Android OS: Apple, which of course makes the signature multi-touch mobile device, the iPhone, apparently asked Google not to implement it, ...